Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Republic Standard

Founded on First Principles
States

EPA Proposal Divides States Over Power Plant Rules

By The Republic Standard News Staff

The Environmental Protection Agency has proposed repealing its remaining greenhouse-gas standards for fossil fuel-fired power plants, drawing sharply different responses from state governments, tribal representatives, medical organizations and environmental groups.

The proposal would rescind the EPA’s 2015 finding that the Clean Air Act gave the agency authority to regulate greenhouse-gas emissions from power plants. If the proposal is finalized and survives court challenges, it would remove the remaining federal greenhouse-gas regulations for fossil fuel-fired electric generating units.

The Trump administration said the action is intended to protect affordable, reliable electricity. A separate final EPA rule that partly repealed emissions standards adopted in 2024 took effect Monday.

States Take Opposing Positions

The comment period for the supplemental proposal closed earlier this month after generating more than 165,000 comments.

A coalition of 22 mostly Democratic-leaning states joined Washington, D.C., New York City, Denver, Chicago and California’s Bay Area in an over-160-page comment. Those governments argued that federal rules are necessary as they confront air pollution and the health and financial costs associated with climate change.

West Virginia and 24 other largely Republican-leaning states submitted a separate comment supporting limits on EPA authority. Those states said federal regulation of fossil-fuel emissions exceeds the agency’s proper role and could damage their economies.

North Dakota strongly supported the supplemental proposal. The state collects a coal conversion tax when coal-generated electricity is produced within its borders.

“Then there are groups of states that want EPA’s authority to be limited, if not eliminated,” said Carrie Jenks, executive director of Harvard Law School’s Environmental & Energy Law Program. Jenks said pending court cases could affect the EPA’s rules.

Tribal and Health Groups Object

The National Tribal Air Association, representing 162 tribes, filed comments opposing the EPA actions. The organization said many fossil-fuel power plants operate on or near American Indian and Alaska Native communities.

More than 70 medical and public-health organizations also opposed the rollbacks, including the American Medical Association, the American Lung Association and several state chapters of the American Academy of Pediatrics. The groups said the changes would harm children and other vulnerable people.

States, public-health organizations and environmental groups have filed legal challenges to EPA rollbacks.

Category: Economy

Tags: Economy, Energy, Environmental Protection Agency, Donald Trump